Shelved Under Murder
Book Review

This Shelved Under Murder book review takes a closer look at a cozy mystery that pairs a book-centered setting with a calm, thoughtful investigation and subtle autumn atmosphere. Rather than focusing on high drama or nonstop action, the story unfolds at a measured pace, allowing relationships, community ties, and quiet tension to shape the mystery. It’s a strong choice for readers who enjoy reflective cozies where intellect, setting, and character connections matter just as much as the whodunit itself.

Shelved Under Murder - Victoria Gilbert

Series: Blue Ridge Library Mysteries
Vibes: Bookish cozy, autumn atmosphere, small-town charm, gentle suspense, quietly comforting

Shelved Under Murder Book Review

This Shelved Under Murder book review is for cozy mystery readers who enjoy stories that blend bookish settings, intellectual puzzles, and a slightly more suspenseful edge—while still staying firmly within cozy territory. As the second installment in the Blue Ridge Library Mystery series, this book feels like a confident continuation, deepening character relationships and raising the stakes just enough to keep things engaging without sacrificing comfort.

Set during October in a charming Virginia town, Shelved Under Murder leans into atmosphere, community, and thoughtful investigation rather than fast-paced action. It’s a cozy that rewards attention, patience, and an appreciation for character-driven storytelling.

The Sleuth:
Bookish, Confident, and Quietly Capable

Amy Webber is a bookish, confident, curious, and relatable sleuth who fits naturally into the role of a knowledgeable helper pulled into the case. She doesn’t force herself into investigations out of ego or recklessness; instead, she’s drawn in because her skills are genuinely useful and her motivations are personal.

One of Amy’s strengths as a protagonist is how grounded she feels. She’s intelligent without being pretentious and confident without being abrasive. Her curiosity is rooted in care—particularly when the case begins to touch her family history—and that emotional connection adds depth to the mystery.

Being inside Amy’s head is an enjoyable experience. Her thought process is clear and methodical, making the investigation feel earned rather than convenient. While art history isn’t necessarily a subject every reader gravitates toward, the way it’s presented here makes it accessible and engaging. Even if it’s not typically your cup of tea, the integration of art research into the mystery feels purposeful and interesting rather than dry or overwhelming.

The Setting:
Warm, Charming, and Lived-In

Taylorsford, Virginia comes across as warm and charming, with the kind of small-town energy that feels real rather than overly idealized. The town isn’t frozen in quaint perfection—it has drama, history, and secrets, all of which add texture to the story.

The fall setting provides a light seasonal backdrop rather than full immersion. While autumn imagery and leaf-peeping season are present, they don’t dominate the narrative. Instead, they subtly enhance the mood, lending a slightly crisp, reflective atmosphere that pairs well with the book’s thoughtful tone.

The Heritage Festival plays a role in the story, but it doesn’t leave a lasting imprint as a centerpiece. It exists more as context—something happening around the characters rather than the driving force of the plot. For readers who enjoy seasonal touches without feeling overwhelmed by them, this balance works well.

Side Characters:
Emotional Anchors

The supporting cast is one of the strongest aspects of Shelved Under Murder. Richard, Kurt Kendrick, and Aunt Lydia stand out as particularly memorable and emotionally grounding characters.

Amy’s relationship with Aunt Lydia is especially touching. It’s warm, sentimental, and layered with shared history, making Amy’s determination to protect her aunt feel deeply personal and justified. Their bond adds emotional weight to the mystery and reinforces the theme of family—both biological and chosen.

Her interactions with the sheriff’s department reflect a careful balancing act. Amy remains friendly and cooperative, but there’s always an undercurrent of tension as she navigates her role as a civilian sleuth. This dynamic feels realistic and adds subtle complexity to the investigation.

Meanwhile, her relationship with Richard is sweet and endearing, offering moments of warmth and gentle romantic tension. It’s the kind of slow-burn connection that cozy readers often appreciate, and it leaves you hoping to see their relationship progress further in future books.

Overall, the side characters contribute emotional warmth and small-town drama, making Taylorsford feel like a fully realized community rather than a backdrop.

The Mystery:
Gentle but Thoughtfully Suspenseful

The mystery itself sits comfortably in the moderate cozy tension range. The crimes are mild and non-graphic, staying well within cozy mystery expectations, but the stakes feel real—especially once the danger begins to touch people Amy cares about.

The plot is comfortably twisty, offering enough complexity to engage readers who enjoy intellectual puzzles without becoming confusing or heavy. There are moments of heightened tension, particularly when Amy, Lydia, Richard, and Kurt find themselves in danger near the end, but these scenes add suspense without tipping the story into distressing territory.

The resolution is satisfying, tying together the art-related clues and personal motivations in a way that feels logical and earned. It closes the case cleanly while still leaving room for character development to continue in future installments.

Vibes Check:
Bookish Comfort with Gentle Suspense

The dominant vibes in Shelved Under Murder include:

• Bookish cozy
• Small-town charm
• Gentle suspense
• Quietly thoughtful mystery

The tone leans more quiet and reflective, with occasional moments of liveliness provided by community interactions and emotional confrontations. This makes the book especially appealing to readers who enjoy cozies that feel calm and contemplative rather than bustling or comedic.

Books themselves aren’t a heavy focal point beyond Amy’s role as a librarian, but the balance between art, history, and mystery is well handled. The intellectual elements enhance the story without overshadowing the characters or emotional core.

Who Will Enjoy This Book Most?

Shelved Under Murder is a great fit for readers who love:

• Art- and history-infused cozy mysteries
• Bookish settings with intellectual puzzles
• Small-town cozies with gentle suspense
• Character-driven series that deepen over time

It’s best read as part of the series, as the background relationships and ongoing dynamics add richness to the story.

My Final Thoughts:
Shelved Under Murder Book Review

This book leaves you feeling content and satisfied, with the comforting sense that both the mystery and emotional threads have been neatly resolved. Even if art history isn’t typically your favorite topic, Shelved Under Murder may surprise you with how engaging it can be when woven thoughtfully into a cozy mystery.

While the audiobook narration wasn’t a personal favorite, the strength of the characters and storyline more than make up for it. The world of Taylorsford feels worth returning to, and the relationships established here provide plenty of incentive to continue the series—perhaps with a bit of spacing between installments.

If you enjoy bookish cozies with a thoughtful pace, warm relationships, and a touch of autumnal suspense, Shelved Under Murder is a rewarding and satisfying read.

Want more? Checkout my printables shop!

Enjoyed My Shelved Under Murder Book Review? If so,
Explore Other Cozy Reads

• Cozy Corner
• Best Cozy Mysteries for Beginners
• Best Cozy Mysteries of 2025
• Pleasant Fall Cozies
• Cozy Mystery Reviews
• Southern Cozy Mysteries
• Cozy Mysteries With Animal Sidekicks
• Cozy Mystery Series You Can Binge
• New Cozy Mystery Releases

Support This Site!

If you enjoy all the free printables provided on this site, please consider showing support by purchasing from my website store or one of my other shops.

Words Are Fun, Cozies Are Fun, Inspired Illustrations, Jennie B Essentials, Paw-sitively Adorable Books, Teachers Pay Teachers

If you would rather donate directly, click (or scan) the image below.

Buy Me A Coffee

Support Your Local Associations!

Cancer

Lupus

Alzheimer's

Your Cozy Word Corner Awaits

Sign Up Today

Receive a special FREEBIE when you sign up!

Seasonal Spotlight

Valentine’s Day Puzzle Bundle

Free Winter Whimsy Fun Pack

Silly Drawing Prompts for Kids: Valentine’s Day

Sugar Cookie Composition Notebook

Cute Penguin Composition Notebook

Cute Winter Bunny Notebook

Silly Drawing Prompts for Kids: Winter

Silly Writing Prompts for Kids: Winter