A Nutcracker Nightmare
Book Review

A Nutcracker Nightmare Book Review

This A Nutcracker Nightmare book review explores a Christmas cozy filled with high school reunion drama, sisterly loyalty, and plenty of chocolate-shop charm. Set against a backdrop of holiday décor and long-buried secrets, this mystery blends nostalgia with scandal in a way that keeps the pages turning. As old classmates reconnect—and clash—the festive atmosphere only heightens the tension, making this story feel both comforting and delightfully dramatic. If you enjoy holiday-themed whodunits with strong family bonds and a steady unraveling of secrets, this one offers a satisfying mix of warmth and intrigue.

A Nutcracker Nightmare - Christina Romeril

A Nutcracker Nightmare - Christina Romeril

Series: Killer Chocolate Mysteries
Vibes: Christmas nostalgia, chocolate-shop cozy, small-town drama, found-family warmth, holiday intrigue

A Nutcracker Nightmare Book Review

If you’re craving a festive cozy packed with drama, chocolate, and sisterly sleuthing, this A Nutcracker Nightmare book review dives into a holiday mystery that delivers both warmth and whodunit tension. The second installment in the Killer Chocolate Mysteries by Christina Romeril blends high school reunion scandal with Christmas sparkle—and it hooked me from the very first chapter.

While this mystery can technically be read as a standalone, I appreciated it even more having read Book One. Understanding the established relationships—especially between the sisters and their close-knit circle—added emotional depth that made the drama hit harder and the stakes feel more personal.

With bludgeoning by nutcracker, old grudges resurfacing, and chocolates woven through nearly every scene, this holiday cozy balances sweetness with just enough bite.

The Sleuth:
Sweet, Stubborn, and Boldly Nosy

Although twin sisters Hanna and Alex co-own the Murder and Mayhem book and chocolate shop, this installment firmly centers Alex as the primary sleuth. She’s sweet and genuinely helpful, but she also has a stubborn streak and a tendency to insert herself right where she probably shouldn’t. And honestly? That’s exactly what makes her such an engaging cozy lead.

Alex is bold when it comes to investigating—she doesn’t hesitate to ask questions or poke into uncomfortable territory. Yet when it comes to her personal life, especially her relationship with Tom, she’s much more cautious and uncertain. That contrast made her feel layered and relatable. She follows a mix of logic and instinct, sometimes letting emotion steer her, particularly when people she cares about are involved.

I’ll admit I did feel a flicker of frustration regarding her handling of the romantic tension with Tom. She entertains the idea of another man without fully understanding Tom’s hesitations, and that emotional misstep adds a subtle thread of personal drama running alongside the mystery. But even that felt realistic rather than contrived.

The twin dynamic remains one of the strongest elements of the book. There’s no competitiveness here—just unwavering support, protectiveness, and a shared determination to clear Hanna’s name when she becomes the prime suspect. Their loyalty anchors the story beautifully.

And Watson, their sleuthing canine? Mostly a cozy bonus… until the end, when he proves he’s more than just adorable background charm.

The Setting:
Festive Reunion with Small-Town Sparkle

This mystery leans fully into its Christmas theme. Between the nutcracker murder weapon and the seasonal atmosphere woven throughout the town of Harriston, the holiday presence is strong and immersive. Even with the high school reunion acting as the central event, the festive vibe never fades into the background.

The reunion itself serves as the perfect storm for secrets to surface. Nostalgia mixes with unresolved tension, and it quickly becomes clear that not everyone is thrilled to reconnect. Old rivalries, cheating scandals, affairs, and even whispers of a love child create a dramatic undercurrent that fuels the suspect list.

Harriston feels like the kind of small town you’d want to visit during the holidays—cozy storefronts, familiar faces, and that comforting sense that everyone knows everyone. The Murder and Mayhem shop plays a major role, especially with Hanna’s chocolates featured frequently throughout the story. The chocolate-making doesn’t feel like a gimmick; it’s integrated naturally into the setting and tone, enhancing the cozy atmosphere.

If anything, the seasonal element only elevates the story rather than distracting from it.

Side Characters:
Found Family at Its Sweetest

The side characters bring life—and occasionally chaos—to the pages. The reunion attendees add layers of drama that make the mystery richer. With so many secrets swirling around Kyle, it’s no surprise suspects begin stacking up quickly.

Kyle himself isn’t exactly mourned heavily. His behavior makes it easier to understand why so many people might have wanted him gone, which adds to the tension without dampening the cozy feel.

The real heart of the supporting cast lies in Alex and Hanna’s close friend group: Tom, Maggie, and Drew. Their presence reinforces the strong found-family vibes that run throughout the series. They support, protect, and occasionally challenge the sisters in ways that feel authentic and grounded.

And while no side character fully tipped into “creepy” territory for me, the layered scandals gave the story an edge that kept the mystery compelling.

The Mystery:
Comfortably Twisty with Holiday Drama

On the cozy scale, this mystery sits at moderate tension. Violence is largely off-page, and while there’s an intense moment involving a stun gun toward the end, nothing ventures into graphic territory. The focus stays on clues, motives, and unraveling long-buried secrets.

The suspect pool grows quickly—almost impressively so. Between reunion drama and Kyle’s questionable behavior, nearly everyone seems to have a motive. The layered scandals keep readers guessing, and I genuinely did not predict the killer.

The motive, however, felt satisfying and justified once revealed. The ending unfolds steadily rather than explosively, allowing the resolution to land in a way that feels earned rather than rushed.

Vibes Check:
Christmasy Chocolate with Nostalgic Drama

The overall tone is comforting but packed with drama. Think:

  • Christmasy
  • Chocolates
  • Nostalgic
  • Found family

It’s a cozy with emotional stakes and reunion scandal simmering under holiday sparkle. The chocolate theme is strong enough that I absolutely wanted a box nearby while listening. This is the kind of mystery that pairs perfectly with seasonal treats and a warm blanket.

It’s not purely soft and fluffy—it carries a good balance of cozy charm and interpersonal drama.

Who Will Enjoy This Book Most?

This mystery is perfect for readers who love:

  • Holiday-themed cozies
  • Sister-led sleuthing duos
  • Chocolate shop settings
  • Nostalgia-fueled small-town drama
  • Fans of Joanne Fluke-style foodie mysteries

I think new cozy readers would absolutely enjoy this one, especially those looking for a festive entry point into the genre. Series readers will likely appreciate it even more for the character continuity and relationship depth.

My Final Thoughts:
A Nutcracker Nightmare Book Review

A Nutcracker Nightmare delivers exactly what I want from a holiday cozy: charm, chocolate, scandal, and sisterly loyalty. The strong twin dynamic, layered reunion drama, and steady unraveling of secrets made this an engaging and satisfying read from start to finish.

With only one more book left in the series, I’m already planning to work it into my reading schedule soon to complete the trio. If you’re in the mood for a Christmas cozy with a little bite behind the sweetness, this one is well worth unwrapping.

Want more? Checkout my printables shop!

Enjoyed My A Nutcracker Nightmare Book Review? If so,
Explore Other Cozy Reads

Have You Read This Cozy Mystery? Share Your Thoughts!

Have you curled up with this cozy mystery already — or is it on your TBR? I’d love to hear your take!

Share a short, spoiler-free review, what you loved (or didn’t), and who you’d recommend it to. Feel free to include photos of your copy, your reading nook, or anything cozy that paired perfectly with your read.

Once approved, your review will appear on its own page and may be featured on this site to help other cozy readers discover their next favorite mystery.

Support This Site!

If you enjoy all the free printables provided on this site, please consider showing support by purchasing from my website store or one of my other shops.

Shop Fun Printables

Words Are Fun, Cozies Are Fun, Inspired Illustrations, Jennie B Essentials, Paw-sitively Adorable Books, Teachers Pay Teachers

If you would rather donate directly, click (or scan) the image below.

Buy Me A CoffeeBuy Me A Coffee

Support Your Local Associations!

Support Your Local Cancer AssociationCancer
Support Your Local Lupus FoundationLupus
Support Your Local Alzheimer's AssociationAlzheimer's

Cozy Mystery Pick for 
the Month of January

Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder - Valerie BurnsTwo Parts Sugar, One Part Murder - Valerie Burns

January's cozy pick features a small-town set in the Midwest, includes an influencer turned baker, a lovable English Mastiff and a new found family. Perfect for curling up a warm drink and a slice of chocolate cake.

Your Cozy Word Corner Awaits

Words Are Fun Links

Sign Up Today

Receive a special FREEBIE when you sign up!