January 2026 Cozy Mystery Reading Wrap-Up and Rankings

Welcome to my January 2026 cozy mystery reading wrap-up and rankings, where I share what I actually read this month and the cozy vibes each mystery brought to my winter reading life.

January reading always feels extra comforting—quiet evenings, slower routines, and that “fresh year” energy where I want stories that are charming, low-stress, and satisfying. This month was a fun blend of post-holiday cozies, foodie mysteries, small-town sleuthing, and a few short reads that were perfect when I wanted something cozy-but-quick.

If you’re looking for cozy mysteries to add to your TBR (or you just enjoy seeing how my reading stacks up month by month), you’re in the right place.

January Cozy Mood in 5 Words
(January 2026 Cozy Mystery Reading Wrap-Up and Rankings)

Festive. Foodie. Small-town. Series-happy. Comfort-first.

This month leaned into:

• Holiday cozies (still 100% welcome in January)
• Food-forward comfort reading
• Animal sidekicks and charming communities
• Craft + bookish cozies
• A few quick, bingeable short reads sprinkled in

Everything I Read in January 2026
(Chronological List)

Here’s the complete list of what I finished this month.

1. Agatha’s First Case — M.C. Beaton (British cozy)
   
2. Murder at the Christmas Cookie Bake-Off — Darci Hannah (Christmas Cookie competition cozy)
   
3. Death of a Mad Hatter — Jenn McKinlay (Hat shop mystery)
   
4. Slashing Through the Snow — Jacqueline Frost  (Christmas tree farm cozy)
   
5. A Killer Sundae — Abby Collette (Ice cream parlor cozy)
   
6. Knitty Gritty Murder — Peggy Ehrhart (Knitting cozy)
   
7. Murder Wears White — Stephanie Blackmoore (Wedding planning cozy)
   
8. Killer Blonde — Laura Levine (Humorous cozy)
   
9. Gingerbread and Grief — Nova Walsh (Christmas cozy)
   
10. Linzer Cookie Murder — Trixie Silvertale (Santa Claus adjacent cozy)
    
11. In Cold Chamomile — Joy Avon (Valentine's cozy)
    
12. Chocolate Grudge — Wendy Meadows (Candy shop cozy)
    
13. The Prickly Pear Murder — Sharon Michaels (Animal sidekick cozy)
    
14. Death and Lemonade — Nova Walsh (Summer cozy)
15. Left Fur Dead — J.M. Griffin (Telepathic rabbit cozy)
16. Owl Be Home for Christmas — Rosie A. Point (Snowy owl cozy)
17. Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder — Valerie Burns (Found family cozy)
18. Shelved Under Murder — Victoria Gilbert (Art history bookish cozy)
19. Murder at the Blueberry Festival — Darci Hannah (Summery blueberry cozy)
20. The Diva Takes the Cake — Krista Davis (Family drama wedding cozy)
    
21. Assailants, Asphalt & Alibis - Tonya Kappes (RV/Camper local legend cozy)

Total cozies read in January 2026: 21

January 2026 Rankings
(January 2026 Cozy Mystery Reading Wrap-Up and Rankings)

This section ranks every cozy mystery I read in January 2026, ordered from my #1 favorite of the month down to the book that ranked lowest for this specific reading period.

These rankings are based entirely on personal enjoyment, cozy atmosphere, memorability, and how well each book fit my January reading mood. A lower ranking doesn’t mean a book wasn’t good—it simply means it didn’t connect with me as strongly as others during this month.

January had a strong lineup overall, so many of these books were separated by very small margins. Seasonal vibes, food-forward comfort, familiar series, and small-town charm all played a big role in how everything ultimately stacked up.

January 2026 Cozy Mystery Rankings
(From Favorite to Least Favorite This Month)

1.

Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder - Valerie Burns

2.

Murder at the Christmas Cookie Bake-Off - Darci Hannah

3.

Slashing Through the Snow - Jacqueline Frost

4.

Knitty Gritty Murder - Peggy Ehrhart

5.

Murder at the Blueberry Festival - Darci Hannah

6.

In Cold Chamomile - Joy Avon

7.

Death and Lemonade - Nova Walsh

8.

A Killer Sundae - Abby Collette

9.

Killer Blonde - Laura Levine

10.

Murder Wears White - Stephanie Blackmoore

11.

Gingerbread and Grief - Nova Walsh

12.

The Diva Takes the Cake - Krista Davis

13.

Shelved Under Murder - Victoria Gilbert

14.

Death of a Mad Hatter - Jenn McKinlay

15.

Owl Be Home for Christmas - Rosie A. Point

16.

Linzer Cookie Murder - Trixie Silvertale

17.

Assailants, Asphalt & Alibis - Tonya Kappes

18.

Agatha's First Case - M.C. Beaton

19.

Left Fur Dead - J.M. Griffin

20.

The Prickly Pear Murder - Sharon Michaels

21.

Chocolate Grudge - Wendy Meadows

How to Read These Rankings

• Top 5: Standout reads I’d easily recommend first
• Middle rankings: Solid, enjoyable cozies that delivered comfort and charm
• Lower rankings: Still cozy and readable, but less memorable or not as aligned with my January mood

This ranking format lets me look back at each month and quickly see what types of cozy mysteries resonated most at that point in the year—while still honoring the fact that every book on this list contributed to a comforting reading month.

The Cozy Patterns I Noticed This Month

Foodie Cozies Dominated (and I loved it)

Between cookies, cake, tea, candy, ice cream, blueberries, and lemonade… January basically read like a snack table. Food-forward cozies were the perfect winter comfort pick.

Holiday cozies still hit in January

I’m officially calling it: Christmas cozies don’t expire on December 26th. Snowy settings + festive towns are still peak cozy in early January.

Animal sidekicks were everywhere (in the best way)

From a telepathic bunny to a giant mastiff to a doxie detective and an arctic fox… January had serious “pet sidekick energy.”

Series comfort kept things easy

This was a strong month for continuing series and sticking with familiar cozy rhythms.

Favorite “Best Of” Categories
for January

• Best Foodie Cozy: Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder
• Best Animal Sidekick: Owl Be Home for Christmas
• Best Bookish Cozy (Library/Books): In Cold Chamomile
• Coziest Small-Town Setting: Slashing Through the Snow
• Best Festival/Event Vibes: Murder at the Christmas Cookie Bake-Off
• Most Comforting Read: Knitty Gritty Murder
• Funniest Read: Killer Blonde
• Lightest Read: The Prickly Pear Murder

New-to-Me Authors I Tried in January

Here are a few new author discoveries I explored this month:

• Valerie Burns (Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder)
• J.M. Griffin (Left Fur Dead)
• Sharon Michaels (The Prickly Pear Murder)

January definitely had a nice mix of “trusted comfort” + “let’s try something new.”

Series I Continued This Month
(January 2026 Cozy Mystery Reading Wrap-Up and Rankings)

• Agatha Raisin (prequel story)
• Beacon Bakeshop Mysteries (Books 2–3)
• Blue Ridge Library Mystery (Book 2)
• A Camper & Criminals Cozy Mystery Series (Book 8)
• Christmas Catastrophe Mysteries (Book 3)
• Christmas Tree Farm Mysteries (Book 3)
• Domestic Diva Mysteries (Book 2)
• Hat Shop Mysteries (Book 2)
• An Ice Cream Parlor Mystery (Book 3)
• Jaine Austen Mysteries (Book 3)
• Knit & Nibble Mysteries (Book 7)
• Moonstone Bakery Mystery Series (Related Book)
• Sugar Creek Mysteries (Book 7)
• Tea and a Read Mysteries (Book 3)
• Wedding Planner Mysteries (Book 2)
• A Very Murder Christmas (Book 2)

Want more? Checkout my printables shop!

January 2026 Cozy Reading Stats

• Total cozies read: 21
• New authors tried: 3
• Most common sub-genre: Foodie cozies
• Most common vibe: Post-holiday comfort + small-town charm
• Most noticeable theme: Festivals, competitions, and community events

Looking Ahead to February 2026

February’s reading plans lean heavily into comfort listening, food-centered cozies, and series I already trust—exactly the kind of reading rhythm I crave during the heart of winter. With shorter days and slower routines, I’m focusing on mysteries that feel immersive, familiar, and easy to sink into.

A mix of classic mystery elegance and modern cozy charm anchors the month. Death on the Nile brings timeless glamour and layered clue work, offering a slower, more atmospheric listening experience. Alongside it are small-town cozies filled with family tension, community drama, and emotionally grounded mysteries that feel personal without being heavy.

Food-forward stories are once again a major theme, from chocolate shops and dumpling houses to tearooms, bakeries, and fiber arts conferences complete with cookies and knitting. Several picks revolve around events gone wrong—Mother’s Day brunches, bridal showers, charity fundraisers, reunions, and conferences—creating that perfect cozy setup where secrets surface in public settings.

Bookish comfort also plays a strong role this month, with bookstore- and library-adjacent mysteries that balance warm community vibes with deeper emotional threads. Familiar series returns, especially those featuring tea shops, hat makers, knitters, and close-knit towns, promise the kind of steady, comforting storytelling that makes February reading feel both cozy and satisfying.

Overall, February 2026 is shaping up to be a month of intentional, comforting listens—stories that prioritize atmosphere, character relationships, and gentle intrigue over speed. It’s less about chasing novelty and more about settling into cozy consistency, one well-loved mystery at a time.

Enjoyed this January 2026 Cozy Mystery Reading Wrap-Up and Rankings? If so,
Discover More
Cozy Mystery Reads

• Best Cozy Mysteries of the Year
• Best Seasonal Cozy Mysteries
• January 2026 Cozy Mystery TBR Goals
• February 2026 Cozy Mystery TBR Goals
• Monthly Cozy Mystery Wrap-Ups & Rankings
• Cozy Mystery Reading Challenges

Final Thoughts on
January 2026 Cozy Mystery Reading Wrap-Up and Rankings

January 2026 was the kind of cozy month I love most: familiar series comfort, food-filled settings, small towns with quirky events, and mysteries that stayed light while still being satisfying.

Once I add my rankings, I’ll have a clear snapshot of what types of cozies I’m most drawn to at the start of the year—and I already know this month is going to influence what I reach for next.

Support This Site!

If you enjoy all the free printables provided on this site, please consider showing support by purchasing from my website store or one of my other shops.

Words Are Fun, Cozies Are Fun, Inspired Illustrations, Jennie B Essentials, Paw-sitively Adorable Books, Teachers Pay Teachers

If you would rather donate directly, click (or scan) the image below.

Buy Me A Coffee

Support Your Local Associations!

Cancer

Lupus

Alzheimer's

Your Cozy Word Corner Awaits

Sign Up Today

Receive a special FREEBIE when you sign up!

Seasonal Spotlight

Valentine’s Day Puzzle Bundle

Free Winter Whimsy Fun Pack

Silly Drawing Prompts for Kids: Valentine’s Day

Sugar Cookie Composition Notebook

Cute Penguin Composition Notebook

Cute Winter Bunny Notebook

Silly Drawing Prompts for Kids: Winter

Silly Writing Prompts for Kids: Winter