Death of a Mad Hatter
Book Review

This Death of a Mad Hatter book review is for cozy mystery readers craving a story that leans into whimsy without sacrificing comfort. Blending British charm, creative details, and gentle intrigue, the book invites you to slow down and savor the experience—from imaginative themed moments to character-driven scenes that feel lighthearted yet grounded. Whether you’re already familiar with the Hat Shop Mystery series or simply browsing for a cozy that offers something a little different, this story sets the stage for a relaxed, curiosity-driven read that pairs perfectly with a cup of tea.

Death of a Mad Hatter - Jenn McKinlay

Series: Hat Shop Mysteries
Vibes: British charm, whimsical elegance, creative cozy, gentle mystery, tea-time comfort

Death of a Mad Hatter
Book Review

If you’re in the mood for a cozy mystery that leans into whimsy, British charm, and creative themes, Death of a Mad Hatter is a delightful fit—especially if you enjoy mysteries that feel just a little different from the usual bakery or knitting shop fare. With its Alice in Wonderland–themed fundraiser, charming hat shop setting, and a mystery that balances gentle tension with cozy comforts, this second book in the Hat Shop Mystery series is a solid pick for seasoned cozy readers.

The Sleuth:
Confident, Flawed, and Endearingly Human

Scarlett Parker is a confident amateur sleuth with a personality that feels refreshingly real. She’s stubborn, impulsive, and occasionally snarky—but also genuinely funny, even if her puns don’t always land with the people around her. That mismatch somehow makes her more relatable, not less. Scarlett doesn’t try to be universally charming; she’s herself, flaws and all.

What makes her especially engaging is her strong sense of loyalty. She values friendships deeply and takes promises seriously, even when doing so complicates her life. Alongside that determination is a thread of self-doubt, particularly about her appearance, which grounds her in a very human way. These moments add warmth and realism, making her feel like someone you could easily imagine chatting with over tea.

She’s proactive without being reckless, confident without being polished, and curious without losing her heart—an excellent balance for a cozy mystery protagonist.

The Setting:
Slightly Posh, Utterly Welcoming

Set in London’s Portobello Road, the setting strikes a wonderful balance between posh and approachable. The ladies’ hat shop, Mim’s Whims, is a cozy centerpiece that feels lived-in and loved, offering a creative twist on the classic “small business cozy” setup.

The standout atmosphere comes from the Alice in Wonderland–themed afternoon tea fundraiser, where the focus is on perfectly themed hats, elegant hospitality, and whimsical details. While Vivian designs the hats, Scarlett brings the event to life as the friendly face of the shop, using her hotel-industry background to make everything feel warm and welcoming. This creative setup adds playful charm to the story and feels refreshingly imaginative, even for seasoned cozy mystery readers—especially those who love themed events.

The London backdrop never feels cold or distant. Instead, it carries a welcoming warmth that invites you in, making it easy to sink into the world and enjoy the experience.

Side Characters:
Heart, Humor, and Balance

Vivian absolutely shines as a side character. She brings humor, emotional warmth, and a grounding presence that balances Scarlett’s impulsive tendencies. Their relationship feels authentic and layered, built on mutual respect and genuine affection.

Beyond Vivian, the surrounding cast contributes to a strong sense of community and friendship rather than full-on found-family vibes. The people in Scarlett’s orbit feel like real individuals with their own perspectives and concerns, adding texture to the story without overwhelming it.

These characters help anchor the mystery emotionally, offering moments of levity, concern, and connection that keep the story feeling cozy—even when the stakes rise.

The Mystery:
Cozy with a Touch of Tension

The mystery itself lands squarely in the moderate cozy range. There’s no gore, no grim darkness—just enough tension to keep you turning pages. The premise is clever, and the investigation unfolds in a way that feels fair and engaging.

While cozy mysteries are usually comfortably curious reads, this one introduces a slightly higher emotional tension when it appears that the victim’s widow may also be in danger. That moment adds a subtle sense of urgency without tipping the story into stressful territory.

The clues are satisfying, the pacing remains gentle, and the resolution includes a twist that makes the ending feel especially rewarding—without spoiling the cozy mood.

Vibes Check:
British Charm and Whimsical Comfort

This book radiates British charm from start to finish. It’s the kind of cozy that makes you want to brew a cup of tea, curl up with a blanket, and maybe even revisit Alice in Wonderland once you’re done reading.

The creativity of the hat-making theme, combined with the elegance of afternoon tea and the playful literary inspiration, gives the story a distinct identity. It’s whimsical without being silly, comforting without being bland.

Who Will Enjoy This Book Most?

Death of a Mad Hatter is perfect for longtime cozy mystery readers who enjoy shop-based mysteries and are looking for something a little different. If you love themed parties, creative settings, and cozies that step outside the usual food-centric formula, this book is an excellent choice.

It’s especially appealing to readers who appreciate:

• Craft or shop-based mysteries with a unique twist
• British-set cozies with charm and warmth
• Moderately twisty mysteries that stay gentle
• Series reads where characters deepen over time

This is best enjoyed as part of the series, as it builds on established relationships and character dynamics. While it may take a little time to fully settle into—much like the first book—it’s ultimately rewarding and leaves a lasting impression once it finds its rhythm.

My Final Thoughts:
Death of a Mad Hatter Book Review

While the story takes a bit to get going, the payoff is absolutely worth it. The whimsical theme, engaging sleuth, and satisfying mystery come together beautifully by the end. Death of a Mad Hatter is a cozy mystery that proves charm and creativity can go hand in hand—and it’s a delightful pick for readers craving a comforting, clever escape with a literary flair.

If you’re ready for a cozy mystery that pairs tea, hats, and a touch of Wonderland magic, this one deserves a spot on your reading list

Want more? Checkout my printables shop!

Enjoyed My Death of a Mad Hatter Book Review? If so,
Explore Other Cozy Reads

• Cozy Corner
• Best Cozy Mysteries for Beginners
• Best Cozy Mysteries of 2025
• Spring Cozy Mystery Picks
• Cozy Mystery Reviews
• Southern Cozy Mysteries
• Cozy Mysteries With Animal Sidekicks
• Cozy Mystery Series You Can Binge
• New Cozy Mystery Releases

Support This Site!

If you enjoy all the free printables provided on this site, please consider showing support by purchasing from my website store or one of my other shops.

Words Are Fun, Cozies Are Fun, Inspired Illustrations, Jennie B Essentials, Paw-sitively Adorable Books, Teachers Pay Teachers

If you would rather donate directly, click (or scan) the image below.

Buy Me A Coffee

Support Your Local Associations!

Cancer

Lupus

Alzheimer's

Your Puzzle Hub Awaits

Sign Up Today

Receive a special FREEBIE when you sign up!

Seasonal Spotlight

Valentine’s Day Puzzle Bundle

Free Winter Whimsy Fun Pack

Silly Drawing Prompts for Kids: Valentine’s Day

Sugar Cookie Composition Notebook

Cute Penguin Composition Notebook

Cute Winter Bunny Notebook

Silly Drawing Prompts for Kids: Winter

Silly Writing Prompts for Kids: Winter