Cherry Cream and Murder
Book Review

This Cherry Cream and Murder book review highlights a cozy mystery that blends English village traditions, culinary comfort, and a steadily unfolding whodunit. With its castle setting, familiar series characters, and a mystery that balances warmth with meaningful tension, this installment offers a reading experience that feels immersive without becoming heavy. It’s the kind of cozy that rewards readers who enjoy character continuity, thoughtful sleuthing, and food-forward details woven naturally into the story.

Cherry Cream and Murder – K.E. O'Connor

Series: Holly Holmes Culinary Mystery Series
Vibes: English village charm, foodie cozy, comfortably suspenseful, warm and witty, traditional with a twist

Cherry Cream and Murder
Book Review

This Cherry Cream and Murder book review is for cozy mystery readers who enjoy English village whodunits with a strong foodie focus, familiar characters, and a mystery that leans into tension without ever losing its comforting core. Set during a longbow competition at Audley Castle, this installment blends tradition, rivalry, and danger in a way that feels lively, engaging, and very bingeable.

As the fifth book in the Holly Holmes Culinary Mystery Series, this story benefits greatly from the groundwork laid in earlier books. Character dynamics feel established and layered, the setting feels like home, and the pacing reflects an author who knows exactly how to keep readers turning pages. While it can be read on its own, this is very much a book that shines brightest for readers who have followed the series from the beginning.

The Sleuth:
Stubborn, Observant, and Relatable

Holly Holmes continues to be a strong and engaging amateur sleuth — stubborn, bold, observant, and unapologetically nosy in the best possible way. Her curiosity feels organic rather than forced, making her investigations believable and satisfying to follow. She doesn’t stumble into clues by accident; she actively thinks, questions, and connects dots in a way that draws the reader into her process.

One of the standout aspects of this book is how clearly we see Holly’s thought process. Her inner reasoning adds depth to the mystery and reinforces why she’s so effective as a sleuth. She does take risks, and at times her actions border on reckless, but those moments feel justified by both her personality and the urgency of the situation.

At this stage in the series, Holly feels seasoned. She’s confident without being arrogant, compassionate without being naïve, and determined without being frustrating. That balance makes her especially appealing to readers who enjoy a sleuth who has grown and evolved over time.

The Setting:
Castle Traditions with Cozy Warmth

Audley Castle serves as a rich and immersive backdrop, managing to feel both grand and welcoming at the same time. Despite the stone walls and historical atmosphere, the setting never feels cold or distant. Instead, it retains a warm, charming tone that fits beautifully within the cozy mystery genre.

The longbow competition is central to the story, not just a decorative event. The murder occurs during the competition, and the traditions, rivalries, and tensions surrounding it shape the entire mystery. This creates a contained, high-interest setting where everyone feels like a potential suspect.

For series readers, the castle feels comfortably familiar, reinforcing the sense that Holly has truly built a life here. Even so, there’s still a quiet emotional pull — especially for longtime fans — wondering whether her future might one day include a return to her bakery.

Side Characters:
Layered Relationships and Loyal Companions

Because this is the fifth book in the series, the side characters feel fully realized and deeply woven into Holly’s life. Friendships are supportive, natural, and emotionally grounding, creating a strong found-family atmosphere that enhances the cozy feel of the story.

Princess Alice adds personality and charm, but Meatball the corgi is an undeniable highlight. He isn’t just there for cuteness — he plays an important role and feels genuinely essential to Holly’s world. Dog lovers and pet cozy fans will especially appreciate how naturally he fits into the narrative.

The broader cast adds depth to the mystery through layered relationships, past tensions, and quiet secrets. Their presence makes the suspect pool feel believable and keeps the story engaging from start to finish.

The Mystery:
Moderate Tension with a Satisfying Twist

The mystery in Cherry Cream and Murder leans more toward tension than gentleness, but it remains firmly within cozy boundaries. There’s no gore or grimness — just steady stakes, well-placed clues, and a sense of urgency that keeps the plot moving.

The twists are handled comfortably and thoughtfully. You may begin to suspect the culprit late in the story, especially if you tend to watch for the least likely option, but the motive adds an extra layer of surprise. Even if you guess who, the why still delivers a satisfying payoff.

Pacing is one of this book’s strengths. The investigation unfolds at a steady, well-balanced rhythm that never drags or rushes. The final act is slightly chaotic in the best way, bringing tension, resolution, and emotional closure together effectively.

Vibes Check:
Foodie Comfort with British Whodunit Drama

The overall vibe blends foodie cozy elements with classic English village mystery energy. Desserts, competition drama, humor, and interpersonal tension all work together to create a lively but comforting reading experience.

There’s a nice balance between lighthearted moments and suspense, making this especially appealing to readers who want a cozy mystery that feels engaging rather than overly gentle. The tone feels confident, polished, and ideal for readers who enjoy a bit more complexity in their cozies.

Who Will Enjoy This Book Most?

Cherry Cream and Murder is a great fit for:

• Foodie cozy mystery fans
• Readers who love British or English village whodunits
• Pet cozy readers, especially dog lovers
• Cozy mystery fans who enjoy ongoing series and layered characters
• Experienced cozy readers who prefer moderate tension

While newer readers can enjoy this book, those who start the series from the beginning will get the most out of the character dynamics and emotional depth.

My Final Thoughts:
Cherry Cream and Murder
Book Review

Cherry Cream and Murder left me feeling satisfied and eager to continue the series. The ending works well emotionally, and while Holly seems completely content living at the castle, part of me is still rooting for her to reclaim her bakery someday.

There’s nothing I would change about this installment. K.E. O’Connor’s writing remains smooth, engaging, and perfectly suited to the cozy mystery genre. This book is a strong example of how a long-running cozy series can maintain comfort while continuing to grow in depth and tension.

For readers already invested in the Holly Holmes Culinary Mystery Series, this is an easy recommendation — and for those who love British foodie cozies with pets, humor, and satisfying twists, it’s well worth your time.

Want more? Checkout my printables shop!

Enjoyed My Cherry Cream and Murder Book Review? If so,
Explore Other Cozy Reads

• Cozy Corner
• Best Cozy Mysteries for Beginners
• Best Cozy Mysteries of 2025
• Spring Cozy Mystery Picks
• Sensational Summer Cozies
• Cozy Mystery Reviews
• Cozy Mysteries With Animal Sidekicks
• Cozy Mystery Series You Can Binge
• New Cozy Mystery Releases

Support This Site!

If you enjoy all the free printables provided on this site, please consider showing support by purchasing from my website store or one of my other shops.

Words Are Fun, Cozies Are Fun, Inspired Illustrations, Jennie B Essentials, Paw-sitively Adorable Books, Teachers Pay Teachers

If you would rather donate directly, click (or scan) the image below.

Buy Me A Coffee

Support Your Local Associations!

Cancer

Lupus

Alzheimer's

Cozy Mystery Pick for 
the Month of January

Two Parts Sugar, One Part Murder - Valerie Burns

January's cozy pick features a small-town set in the Midwest, includes an influencer turned baker, a lovable English Mastiff and a new found family. Perfect for curling up a warm drink and a slice of chocolate cake.

Your Cozy Word Corner Awaits

Sign Up Today

Receive a special FREEBIE when you sign up!